HomeScam Watch & Blacklist
Prop Trading Consumer Watchdog

Prop Firm Scam Watch & Blacklist Registry

An independent, evidence-backed repository tracking insolvent, legally enjoined, and high-risk prop trading firms. Updated continuously to protect retail traders from unrecoverable fee losses and predatory contract clauses.

Database audited weekly against CFTC enforcement dockets, UK FCA alerts, court filings, and verified Trustpilot arbitration logs.

Audited Blacklisted & Inactive Prop Firms (6)

MyForexFunds (MFF)

CFTC / OSC InjunctionCanada / United States

Incident Date: September 2023

Estimated Exposure / Losses$310,000,000+ total gross deposits

Primary Breach / Violation

Regulatory asset freeze, fraudulent execution manipulation, misrepresentation of simulated vs live trades.

Case Investigation

In September 2023, the US CFTC and Canadian OSC issued emergency asset freeze orders against Traders Global Group Inc. (MyForexFunds) and CEO Murtuza Kazmi. Regulators alleged that MFF operated as the counterparty to customer trades, assessed deceptive account termination fees, and actively traded against profitable users using specialized software.

Red Flags Identified

  • Counterparty conflict of interest
  • Hidden server execution markups
  • Unregistered retail commodity transactions
Recommended Safe Alternative

FTMO

10+ year flawless operational history, EU regulated entity, audited by Deloitte with over $160M paid to traders.

The Funded Trader (TFT) - Original Entity

Suspended Operations (2024)United States

Incident Date: March 2024

Estimated Exposure / Losses$8,000,000+ estimated unpaid payouts and challenge credits

Primary Breach / Violation

Mass payout backlog, CEO departure, sudden platform shutdown, migration failures.

Case Investigation

Following severe platform migration issues after MetaQuotes broker licensing terminations, TFT experienced extreme payout delays. In March 2024, Easton Consulting announced an abrupt suspension of all operations, leaving tens of thousands of active accounts and millions in pending payout requests in limbo.

Red Flags Identified

  • Excessive 85%+ promo code stacking
  • Payout backlog extending past 30 days
  • Repeated platform migrations without execution parity
Recommended Safe Alternative

Funding Pips

Resilient infrastructure with Match-Trader/cTrader/DXtrade, on-demand payouts, and transparent zero-breach track record.

True Forex Funds (TFF)

Permanent InsolvencyHungary

Incident Date: February 2024

Estimated Exposure / LossesUndisclosed (€15M+ estimated market exposure)

Primary Breach / Violation

MetaQuotes license termination, insolvency declaration, unfulfilled customer refund guarantees.

Case Investigation

True Forex Funds ceased all trading services on February 2024 after MetaQuotes abruptly revoked its broker license. Despite promising proprietary platform launches, the firm filed for official insolvency and shuttered customer support channels in May 2024.

Red Flags Identified

  • Single-point-of-failure platform reliance
  • Lack of reserve treasury transparency
  • Unannounced cessation of operations
Recommended Safe Alternative

The5ers

Operating continuously since 2016, legal entity registered in Israel/UK, institutional liquidity via tier-1 brokers.

Kortana FX

Extreme Risk / Rule AlterationsSaint Vincent & the Grenadines

Incident Date: Mid 2024

Estimated Exposure / LossesMultiple 5-figure payout rejections reported

Primary Breach / Violation

Arbitrary retroactive rule enforcement, disqualifications on HFT passed accounts requesting payouts.

Case Investigation

Kortana aggressively promoted rapid challenge passing via High Frequency Trading (HFT) algorithms. However, once users reached funded status and requested payouts, accounts were routinely disqualified under broad 'toxic order flow' and 'latency arbitrage' clauses.

Red Flags Identified

  • Promoting HFT passes while refusing HFT payouts
  • Offshore registration with zero regulatory oversight
  • Retroactive rule changes without advance notice
Recommended Safe Alternative

Topstep

Regulated futures prop firm with CME direct market access (DMA), verified daily payouts, and 12+ years of operating integrity.

SurgeTrader

Abrupt LiquidationUnited States

Incident Date: May 2024

Estimated Exposure / Losses$10,000,000+ trader challenge value

Primary Breach / Violation

Overnight operational cessation following institutional brokerage termination.

Case Investigation

In May 2024, SurgeTrader abruptly posted a notice on their website stating that their trading technology partner had terminated services without notice, forcing an immediate and permanent closure of all active challenge and funded accounts.

Red Flags Identified

  • Total dependency on single broker white-label
  • Immediate closure without orderly wind-down period
  • Uncompensated trader account terminations
Recommended Safe Alternative

FundedNext

Dual multi-platform licensing (cTrader, MT5, DXtrade), automated payouts, and audited global trader community.

Skilled Funded Trader (SFT)

Collateral FailureUnited States

Incident Date: March 2024

Estimated Exposure / LossesEstimated $2,500,000+

Primary Breach / Violation

Shared infrastructure collapse alongside parent management entity.

Case Investigation

As an affiliate sister brand sharing backend management with The Funded Trader, Skilled Funded Trader suspended operations simultaneously when Easton Consulting's financial processing infrastructure locked up.

Red Flags Identified

  • Undisclosed white-label ownership clusters
  • Shared financial clearing with distressed operators
  • Lack of dedicated customer payout reserves
Recommended Safe Alternative

Alpha Capital Group

Proprietary execution infrastructure via ACG Markets, UK FCA-registered entity directors, and direct liquidity feeds.

Interactive Safety Audit

7-Point Prop Firm Red Flag Safety Checker

Evaluating a new prop firm or an aggressive 90% discount promotion? Check the box for any warning sign present in their terms of service, platform, or Discord community to calculate instantaneous scam risk.

Unilateral Payout Denials Under Vague 'Hedging' or 'Latency' Termscritical

The firm accepts challenge fees with open rules, but once an account requests a 4-figure payout, risk teams cite retroactive rules regarding microsecond tick latency, tick scalping, or cross-account hedging without transaction logs.

How to detect: Check Discord complaints and Trustpilot 1-star reviews for patterns where traders receive generic disqualification templates only upon payout requests.

Absence of a Tier-1 Regulated Liquidity Provider / Broker Partnercritical

Legitimate prop firms contract with regulated Prime Brokers or institutional brokerages (e.g. Purple Trading, Eightcap, Match-Prime, DXtrade institutional feeds). Scam operators run internal B-book simulated bridges with artificially inflated slippage.

How to detect: Look at the server name in MT4/MT5 or cTrader. If the server name is identical to the marketing company without an institutional clearing broker, execution is fully synthetic.

Flash 90%+ Lifetime Discounts & Impossible Profit Splits (95%+)high

When a firm runs perpetual 80% to 90% discount flash sales with free retries and 95% profit splits, their cash flow is reliant entirely on new challenge deposits rather than funded trader liquidity buffers.

How to detect: If discount percentages keep inflating every week, the firm is likely operating a Ponzi-style challenge liquidity cycle to meet pending payout queues.

Unlicensed Proprietary Tech Stacks with Simulated Fill Manipulationhigh

Following MetaQuotes' crackdown on unverified prop firms in early 2024, some low-tier operators deployed custom web terminals where slippage on market orders can be manually dialed up on profitable traders.

How to detect: Test order execution speed during London/NY open. If slippage consistently skews negative by 3+ pips on limit orders, synthetic fill degradation is active.

Crypto-Only Deposits & Payouts With Zero KYC Compliancehigh

While crypto payout rails (USDT ERC20/TRC20) are convenient, prop firms that refuse any bank wires, Rise, or Deel and operate from anonymous shell companies in Saint Vincent or the Seychelles carry zero legal trader recourse.

How to detect: Inspect company footer for a verified registered legal entity, registration number, and operating headquarters.

Trailing Drawdown Calculated on Unrealized Floating High-Water Markwarning

Firms that lock in trailing liquidation thresholds during live intraday open positions rather than balance or End-of-Day (EOD) make passing mathematically improbable for swing traders.

How to detect: Read the drawdown FAQ carefully: confirm whether the drawdown moves up when an order spikes into unrealized profit before closing.

Repeated Extensions of Payout Processing Windows Beyond 14 Dayscritical

Firms shifting from '24-hour payouts' to 'under risk review for 14-30 business days' are almost always experiencing cash-flow illiquidity or freezing payouts prior to shutting down.

How to detect: Monitor trader communities for sudden surges in 'Pending Payout' status tickets lingering over 10 days.

Safety Audit Score
0/ 7 Red Flags Triggered
Assessed Risk Tier

Clean / Low Risk

No obvious red flags detected. Still verify broker LP and terms.

Looking for a verified safe firm?
Investigation Blueprint

How Prop Firm Scams Operate: The Anatomy of a Collapse

Understanding the mechanical vulnerabilities and economic incentives behind unbacked prop firms is the best way to safeguard your trading career.

1

The Flash Discount Acquisition Trap

A firm launching 80% to 90% coupon sales with lifetime 95% profit splits is not offering value; it is suffering an urgent cash-flow shortfall. When incoming challenge deposits slow, these operators lack sufficient liquidity reserves to fulfill pending 5-figure trader withdrawal queues.

2

Retroactive & Vague Rule Enforcements

Scam operators rarely deny challenges upfront. They allow traders to pass Phase 1 and 2 freely. The predatory behavior strikes upon requesting a payout: risk desks invoke obscure clauses regarding latency exploitation, micro-lot hedging, or trade duration inconsistencies to void profits.

3

Single-Broker Technological Fragility

Many collapsed entities relied on single white-label arrangements without proprietary API bridges. When regulatory pressure or tech providers terminate connections, the firm faces immediate operational shutdown without trader capital segregation.

5 Steps to Take If a Prop Firm Refuses Your Legitimate Payout

STEP 01

Export Complete CSV Logs

Download ticket IDs, open/close timestamps, slippage, and swap fees before portal access is revoked.

STEP 02

Document Written Justification

Request the exact rule clause violated in writing with timestamped server logs from support.

STEP 03

Initiate Bank/Card Chargeback

Submit evaluation fee receipts and proof of unrendered service to your card issuer under dispute code 4853.

STEP 04

Public Community Warning

Publish objective evidence on Trustpilot, Reddit r/Forex, and Discord to prevent other traders from depositing.

STEP 05

Regulatory Submission

File an official complaint with the consumer protection bureau in the firm's registered jurisdiction.

Audited Knowledge Base

Frequently Asked Questions About Prop Firm Scams

What happens to trader funds when a prop firm gets shut down by regulators?

Unlike regulated retail brokerages where client capital is segregated in Tier-1 bank accounts (under FSCS, CySEC, or ASIC insurance schemes), prop trading evaluation fees and simulated profit split balances are treated as general commercial revenue. When an offshore prop firm is frozen (such as during the CFTC injunction against MyForexFunds), payouts are indefinitely halted pending court receivership, leaving traders with virtually zero automated deposit recovery.

Can I do a credit card chargeback if a prop firm refuses my payout?

Yes. Under VISA and Mastercard dispute guidelines, if a merchant fails to honor its service level agreement, changes terms retroactively, or denies payouts without documented breach evidence, you can file a chargeback under 'Services Not Provided' or 'Misrepresentation of Service' within 120 to 180 days of transaction. Having exported trading logs, Discord chat transcripts, and formal withdrawal confirmation emails dramatically increases chargeback dispute win rates.

Why do B-book prop firms fail when traders start requesting large payouts?

In a 100% simulated B-book model, the prop firm does not route trader positions to live interbank liquidity. Payouts are funded directly out of the firm's cash treasury—primarily accumulated from new challenge fee failures. If market conditions become highly trending and a wave of profitable traders all hit 10%+ gains simultaneously while new challenge sales plateau, the firm faces a liquidity deficit. Weak firms respond by citing vague 'gambling' or 'latency' rules to reject payouts before entering insolvency.

How can I verify if a prop firm is financially solvent before buying a challenge?

Look for four institutional hallmarks: (1) Audited financial statements or third-party proof of reserves (e.g., FTMO's Deloitte audits); (2) Multi-broker execution redundancy with independent regulated brokers (e.g. Purple Trading, Eightcap, Match-Prime); (3) Longevity through market cycles (minimum 3+ years of uninterrupted operations); and (4) Regulated futures contracts (CME direct routing via Topstep or Apex) where payouts are backed by live clearing margin.

What is the difference between an evaluation breach and an illegal payout denial?

An evaluation breach occurs when an objective, pre-stated rule is violated (such as breaching the 5% daily loss limit or holding an unhedged position through high-impact news if strictly prohibited in the contract). An illegal payout denial occurs when a trader satisfies all profit and drawdown targets, but the firm retrospectively introduces unwritten 'toxic flow', 'inconsistent trade duration', or 'abusive hedging' rules to cancel legitimate earnings.